Loading prices, five years of statements and peers…
The first visit to a stock takes a few seconds; repeat visits are cached.
The first visit to a stock takes a few seconds; repeat visits are cached.
XETRA · Germany · Banks - Regional
The model's numbers as sentences. Every figure comes from the live data and your inputs, so the story changes when you change an input.
Valued above its peers on earnings
At 14.2x trailing earnings, Commerzbank AG trades 37% above the median of 3 peers (10.4x).
At 1.2x book value, Commerzbank AG trades 42% below the median of 3 peers (2.1x).
Return on equity was 6.8% in 2025, below the 8.5% a year shareholders require (the cost of equity). A simple rule, fair P/B = (ROE − g) ÷ (cost of equity − g), gives about 0.7x against 1.2x today, if that return lasts.
Earnings yield is 7.0% (trailing earnings ÷ price) against 4.9% on a 10-year government bond: more profit per euro of price than the bond pays, though profits are less certain than interest.
Business health grade C (50 out of 100): shows a mixed picture, with 2 strengths and 2 red flags (top concern: thin profitability).
Educational, not investment advice. “Favourable” means the numbers lean in today's price's favour; “Caution” means the price asks a lot of the future.
Every valuation range side by side, against today's price and the value estimate. Per share, in EUR.
| Range | Low | Mid | High |
|---|---|---|---|
| P/B comps (25th to 75th percentile) | €43.62 | €65.58 | €73.47 |
| P/E comps (25th to 75th percentile) | €25.86 | €27.55 | €32.86 |
| Analyst targets (12 analysts, low to high) | €31.60 | €41.80 | €45.00 |
| 52-week share price (trading range) | €29.32 | – | €43.37 |
Is this a good, honest business, not just a cheap one? Published screens on the reported annual accounts (2022–2025), plus plain ratios. Screens, not verdicts: read the accounts before relying on any of them.
Grade C (50/100): shows a mixed picture, with 2 strengths and 2 red flags (top concern: thin profitability).
Piotroski F-score (Joseph Piotroski, 2000): nine pass-or-fail tests of profitability, debt, liquidity and efficiency, each comparing the latest year with the one before. 7 or more is strong; 3 or fewer is weak.
Altman Z'' (Edward Altman, 1995, the version for non-manufacturers and emerging markets): combines working capital, retained earnings, operating profit and book equity relative to the balance sheet. Above 2.60 is the safe zone, below 1.10 the distress zone.
Beneish M-score (Messod Beneish, 1999): eight ratios that, in his study, separated companies later found to have manipulated earnings. Above −1.78 resembles that pattern. It is a prompt to read the notes to the accounts, not an accusation.
Grade: a 0 to 100 blend (Piotroski 40%, Altman 20%, Beneish 15%, the ratios 25%, re-weighted when a part is missing): A from 80, B from 65, C from 50, D from 35, E below.
All three screens were built on US companies and annual accounts from Yahoo Finance, which can be incomplete. Lenders, insurers and holding companies get financial-firm ratios instead of the Altman and Beneish screens.
Price targets and ratings from the brokers' analysts who cover the stock, as Yahoo collects them. Their opinion, not this app's; set against the model so you can see where you differ.
12 analysts' average 12-month target is €41.80, +10.6% against today's €37.78 (median €42.00). The range runs from €31.60 to €45.00.
Your value estimate of €46.60 is 11% above the analysts' average.
Targets are usually for 12 months ahead and tend to run optimistic; brokers that cover a company often do business with it. Counts and targets come from different updates, so they may not match exactly.
How much the shares have swung and how far they have fallen over five years. Risk repeats far more reliably than direction, so this is the honest kind of forecast: how far the price may move, not which way.
Loading five years of prices…
For a lender, an insurer or an investment holding company, debt is raw material rather than financing, so free cash flow to the firm and the WACC bridge don't describe the business. The value above uses peer P/E and P/B only.
Found from Yahoo's related stocks in the same industry; multiples rebuilt here so currencies match. Untick a peer to drop it, or add your own.
| Company | In median | EV/EBITDA | P/E | EV/Sales | P/B | Op. margin | Rev. growth |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Deutsche Bank Aktiengesellschaft DBK.DE Banks - Regional | – | 9.1x | -1.3x | 0.7x | 33.6% | 2.8% | |
| Allianz SE ALV.DE Insurance - Diversified | 3.1x | 14.4x | – | 2.6x | 13.7% | 12.1% | |
| Münchener Rückversicherungs-Gesellschaft Aktiengesellschaft in München MUV2.DE Insurance - Reinsurance | – | 10.4x | 1.2x | 2.1x | 17.3% | 1.3% | |
| Median of included | 3 | 3.1x | 10.4x | 1.2x | 2.1x | ||
| Commerzbank AG | – | – | 14.2x | 4.0x | 1.2x | 0.0% | 4.6% |
| Implied value per share | 25th pct | Median | 75th pct |
|---|---|---|---|
| EV/EBITDA × EBITDA + net cash | – (3.1x) | – (3.1x) | – (3.1x) |
| P/E × earnings per share | €25.86 (9.7x) | €27.55 (10.4x) | €32.86 (12.4x) |
| P/B × book value per share | €43.62 (1.4x) | €65.58 (2.1x) | €73.47 (2.4x) |
| EV/Sales × revenue + net cash (check only) | €7.30 (1.2x) | €7.30 (1.2x) | €7.30 (1.2x) |
| Peer value (average of median P/E and median P/B prices) | €46.56 |
Is today's multiple high or low for this stock? Its P/E (price ÷ earnings per share) or P/B (price ÷ book value per share) month by month, against the range it has traded in.
Loading ten years of monthly prices…
Three pieces of evidence that lead to a view. The client summary button copies all of this as text.
Commerzbank AG (CBK.DE), valuation summary, 1 Nov 2026 Value estimate €46.60 (+23.3% vs today's price of €37.78). • DCF (base case): not meaningful with these inputs per share. WACC 5.95%, terminal growth 3.0%; terminal value is 84% of enterprise value. • Peers: €46.56 per share (average of median P/E and median P/B prices; 3 peers). • Scenarios: bear -€21.74, base -€23.47, bull -€23.37; probability-weighted -€23.01. • What the price implies: outside the range tested for 2026E–2030E, against 7.0% in this forecast. • Monte Carlo: 0% of 2,000 simulated outcomes are above today's price; middle 80% -€42.47 to -€13.99. • Key assumptions (base): revenue growth 9.3% → 7.9% → 6.9% → 6.0% → 5.0%; EBIT margin 0.0% to 0.0%; tax 29.7%. • Checks: to review: The DCF gives a positive value per share; Scenario values are in order: bear ≤ base ≤ bull. Data: Yahoo Finance via yahoo-finance2 (unofficial; delayed prices), as of 1 Nov 2026. Educational model, not investment advice.
5 pass, 2 to review.
What the model uses, from Yahoo Finance via yahoo-finance2 (unofficial; delayed prices). Edit any number that looks wrong; your edits stay in this browser and are marked.
| EUR mn | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | Avg ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | growth 7.7% | ||||
| EBIT (operating profit) | margin 0.0% | ||||
| D&A | 6.8% | ||||
| Profit before tax | |||||
| Tax | rate 29.7% | ||||
| Capex | 8.3% | ||||
| Increase in working capital | 1260.2% of Δrev |
| Cash and short-term investments (EUR mn) | |
| Borrowings (EUR mn) | |
| Lease liabilities (EUR mn) | |
| Minority interests (EUR mn) | |
| Dividends since the balance sheet (EUR mn) |
| Revenue, trailing 12 months (EUR mn) | |
| EBITDA, trailing 12 months (EUR mn) | |
| Net income, trailing 12 months (EUR mn) | |
| Shares outstanding (mn) |
Years are calendar fiscal years. Shares: 1,080,847,095. Price €37.78 at Fri, 30 Oct 2026 16:35:19 GMT.